Training as Punishment

When reviewing an accident investigation form, how many times have you seen the suggested corrective action listed as re-training? Often this is because a Supervisor often thinks that re-training is really the best solution especially if the accident is believed to have happened because information that an individual should have learned in a training class was not applied and therefore, an accident occurred. Suggesting re-training as the corrective action is a fast and easy response even if it is not likely to solve the problem or prevent future similar accidents from occurring. Training is beneficial when there is a lack of knowledge or skills and if an employee has those but fails to use that knowledge and those skills correctly, training or re-training is not the answer.

In other cases, requiring an employee to sit in another 8-hour long boring safety training class or in front of a long computer based training program is seen as serving two purposes: To remind the employee of the information once again and second, as a sort of punishment. There are many bad safety training programs out there and usually, poor content or delivery is not deliberate. When the training experience is something to be dreaded, it appeals to supervisors looking to somehow punish employees for bad behavior.

Training and re-training should not be used as a punishment and often, training is not the answer for a variety of safety problems. If training is thought of as a punishment, any future new training you try to get the workforce excited about will not be seen in a positive light. An important part of increasing the amount of information trainees remember and use back on the job is getting them motivated to learn in the first place. Once training is used as a weapon, it is going to be very difficult to flip the coin and get trainees excited about attending any training in the future. Additionally, if you found yourself forced into a training situation because of something you did wrong, what is your mindset going to be like? In order for training to be effective, trainees need to be comfortable, both mentally and physically. If a trainee feels as if they are “sitting in the corner wearing a dunce cap,” very little of the training is going to be absorbed, and the cycle starts again. Additionally, future training initiatives will be affected as well. Do not use training as a punishment and if you already do, stop and start working on your way to building a safety training program that does more than just allow a company to check off boxes.

PS – Sign up for the free Safety Training newsletter to get more great safety training tips and resources delivered directly to your inbox. Sign-Up Here!


1 thought on “Training as Punishment

  1. Oh my gosh…how many times have I sent teams back to the drawing board when “re-train” is their proposed action. Not only the person involved in the accident, but usually they want to re-train everyone, so the whole group gets punished! Me: Did he know what he was supposed to do? Team: Yes. Me: Then what are you going to train him on? Team: *silence*


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s